Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co – Columbus, IN: Hours, Menu & Directions

Opening hours

Eastern Time

Opening hours have not been published for this bakery yet. Call (812) 552-5359 to check today's hours. Know the hours? Send them to us.

Tap for directions

1109 16th St, Columbus, IN 47201

Google Maps Apple Maps Waze Bing Maps

Address1109 16th St, Columbus, IN 47201

Phone(812) 552-5359

StyleCookie shop

CountyBartholomew County

Time zoneEastern Time

From city center0.4 mi west

About Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co

Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co serves Columbus from 1109 16th St, about 0.4 mi west of central Columbus.

It is one of 14 bakeries and sweet shops we list in Columbus, which works out to one bakery per 3,764 residents. If you want to compare, Donut Central sits 0.4 mi from here.

Hours were not published with this listing. Most cookie shops in Columbus open in the early morning, but phoning (812) 552-5359 first is a good idea.

What to order

Typical items at a cookie shop like this one — the bakery's own selection may differ.

Full menu

Classic cookies

White chocolate macadamiaButtery cookie with creamy white chocolate chips and roasted macadamia nuts for a sweet, crunchy contrast.
Frosted sugar cookieThick, cakey sugar cookie spread with pastel buttercream and sprinkles; soft enough to bend rather than snap.
Molasses gingerChewy, crackle-topped cookie with dark molasses, ginger and cloves, rolled in coarse sugar for sparkle.
Chocolate chipButter-rich cookie with crisp golden edges, a chewy center and pools of semisweet chocolate; the benchmark of any cookie case.

Gourmet & stuffed cookies

Chocolate chip walnutThick, six-ounce New York-style cookie with chunky walnuts and dark chocolate, crisp outside and almost gooey inside.
Cookie butter stuffedBrown sugar cookie with a molten center of spiced cookie butter, warm and caramel-like when broken open.
Hazelnut spread stuffedChocolate chip cookie hiding a pocket of chocolate-hazelnut spread that stays soft and oozy after baking.
Birthday cake cookieVanilla cookie packed with rainbow sprinkles and white chocolate, tasting like boxed birthday cake in chewy form.

Bars & brownies

Raspberry oat barButtery oat crumble base and topping sandwiching a layer of tart raspberry jam; rustic and fruity.
Lemon squareShortbread crust under a smooth, tangy lemon filling, finished with a snowfall of powdered sugar.
Cheesecake brownieFudgy brownie batter swirled with vanilla cheesecake, creating marbled tops with creamy and chewy pockets.
Fudge brownieDense, chewy brownie with a crackly top and a dark, almost truffle-like interior made with cocoa and melted chocolate.

Photos

All photos

Choc-Chip-Cookie — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

ChocolateChipSmile — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

Chocolate chip cookies on cutting board — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

Decorated sugar cookies 2 — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

Visitor reviews

Write a review

No reviews yet. Been to Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co? Your review helps other people decide — be the first to write one.

Questions about Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co

What are Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co's hours?

We have not verified a weekly schedule for Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co yet. Call (812) 552-5359 to confirm before visiting.

Where is Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co located?

Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co is at 1109 16th St, Columbus, IN 47201. Tap the map on this page to open turn-by-turn directions.

What is the phone number for Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co?

The listed phone number is (812) 552-5359.

What should I order at Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co?

As a cookie shop, typical picks include White chocolate macadamia, Frosted sugar cookie, Chocolate chip walnut, and Cookie butter stuffed. See the full menu page for more.

What other bakeries are near Sugar Bayer's Cookie Co?

Nearby options include Donut Central (0.4 mi), Farmhouse Favorites (0.5 mi), and Ahlemeyer Bakery (0.6 mi).